ARGAN SA ($ARG.PA) is a French REIT that gives a 5.5% dividend yield right this moment, but in addition presents a possibility to continue to grow revenues sooner or later. The principle clients of the corporate consist on nice well-known firms like Carrefour, L’Oreal, DHL, Aldi, Decathlon, Amazon, or BMW.
Key Highlights:
- ARGAN combines a excessive dividend yield with long-term income development
- Pores and skin within the recreation: the administration owns over 37% of the enterprise
- Making use of a good valuation method, ARGAN trades at a reduction
The enterprise mannequin:
ARGAN’s enterprise consists on renting premium logistics services. They will construct, develop or purchase warehouses, after which lease it, caring for the property administration throughout the entire lease. The corporate was created in 2000 by Jean-Claude LE LAN, who continues to be the Chairman of the corporate. Listed in 2007, proper earlier than the Nice Monetary Disaster, the corporate has returned over 321% plus dividends.
Pores and skin within the recreation:
ARGAN is an organization with a market capitalization of 1.6 billion Euros. As we’ve mentioned earlier than, the founder continues to be within the firm, however not simply as an worker; his household nonetheless owns 37% of the shares excellent. This provides him and his household a long-term imaginative and prescient, since their wealth is tied to the efficiency of the enterprise. Predica, a subsidiary of Crédit Agricole Assurances, has owned 15% of the corporate for a very long time, serving as a superb counterweight for the household’s affect throughout the enterprise.
The present valuation:
ARGAN has generated 137 million Euros in Recurring Web Earnings in 2024, up 9% from the earlier yr. Which means the corporate is at the moment buying and selling at 11.6 occasions recurring earnings. For comparability, the present earnings ratio of the SP500 is 28 occasions.
The EPRA NAV NTA of the corporate, which is the Web Tangible Worth of the belongings, stays at 85.5 Euros per share. With a present worth per share of 63.30 Euros, we’re buying the corporate’s belongings at a 35% low cost to truthful worth. This worth has grown by 8% in 2024, and is anticipated to continue to grow in 2025.
For 2025, the corporate expects to extend its income by 6%, given new tasks and the listed will increase in worth of the present tenants; and its web recurring earnings by 11%, to 151 million Euros.
However is that this low cost?
A good valuation:
ARGAN has a skillful administration that has overcome troublesome occasions just like the Nice Monetary Disaster whereas delivering distinctive returns to shareholders. Additionally, their wealth is tied to the enterprise, so they’re incentivized to make ARGAN a profitable enterprise.
I think about two methods to soundly method the valuation of ARGAN.
First, a a number of on the web recurring income. However there’s a trick right here. In 2021, the corporate managed to safe 500 million euros by a bond with a 1% rate of interest, which is due in November 2026. That is principally free cash that the corporate is and has been utilizing. Nevertheless, as soon as the due date arrives, they’ll need to refinance this cash. Most likely not the total quantity, but when they did, refinancing at a 3.5% rate of interest would scale back web earnings by about 12.5 million euros.
Thus, I think about that the corporate’s earnings energy stays at 140 million Euros in 2025, being very conservative, which at a a number of of 15 occasions (according to worldwide friends), provides us a margin of security of over 30%.
Second, it’s additionally truthful to worth the corporate at ebook worth. It will in all probability be smart to use a premium to it, given the higher than the typical high quality of the corporate’s belongings. However being conservative, and pondering of ebook worth as a superb valuation technique, the corporate additionally trades at a 30% low cost right this moment.
If the corporate traded at a premium, which I feel is probably going, the low cost might go as much as 57% utilizing a multiplier of earnings of 18 occasions, or to 48% if we utilized a ten% premium on the ebook worth of the corporate.
Not all the things is ideal:
Alternatives exist for a cause within the inventory market. And I discover 4 causes for ARGAN to be low cost:
1. Debt
Though the corporate has been deleveraging its steadiness sheet these days, the debt to belongings ratio is comparatively excessive. The present Mortgage to Worth ratio of the corporate is 43.1%, which implies that debt funds 43% of the belongings; and the Debt to EBITDA ratio stays at 9.2 occasions. In 2023, these ratios have been 49.7% and 11 occasions, respectively, which reveals the hassle of the corporate to deleverage the steadiness sheet whereas nonetheless paying over 3 euros per share in dividends.
The present price of debt is 2.25%, in contrast with 2.30% in 2023, and is anticipated to go right down to 2.10% in 2025. 22.13% of the rental earnings is destined to curiosity on loans, whereas 22.54% was destined in 2023.
Sooner or later, the plan of the corporate is to maintain decreasing the debt whereas investing to develop extra. They plan to finance new investments promoting their current belongings. The standards they may observe is: seniority (older services will likely be offered, ideally); profitability (services with decrease profitability will likely be offered, ideally); and ESG causes (services with larger CO2 emissions, that are sometimes older, will ideally be offered first).
2. Capital enhance
To battle the excessive impression of debt on the corporate, coupled with the upper rates of interest state of affairs that we’ve lived throughout the previous two years, the administration determined to extend the capital in 2024. With a worth of 74 euros per share, the corporate created 2 million new shares, valuing the corporate at 1.7 billion euros.
Though the corporate disclosed that this capital enhance was focusing on new investments, it is usually a measure to adjust to their debt covenants and to keep up their BBB- ranking by S&P. Capital will increase are hardly ever favored by traders, because it typically indicators overleverage and a possible mismanagement.
3. Writedowns
The French REIT business has been impacted throughout the previous years of huge writedowns. REITS are required to worth their belongings at truthful worth, and in 2022 and 2023 ARGAN needed to writedown its belongings, decreasing its ebook worth. In 2024 this development has reverted, though some rivals are nonetheless going by it.
The overvaluation of the ebook worth is all the time a danger relating to REITs, and the latest writedowns have scared traders. Nevertheless, ARGAN isn’t too affected by this, because the services they personal are comparatively new (11.6 years as a mean), and warehouses are much less affected by overvaluations than housing.
4. Focus of purchasers
Carrefour, ARGAN’s fundamental tenant, accounts for 29% of the rental earnings of the corporate. This may increasingly pose a danger to the corporate in the long run. Nevertheless, the typical mounted size of the leases is over 5 years, with 43% of the leases with a time period of over 6 years from 2024. Apart from, the corporate has been managing completely the occupancy ratio, which has been 100% up to now two years, and hasn’t been decrease than 99% since 2016.
Conclusion:
ARGAN is a enterprise that’s buying and selling under its truthful worth. With a reduction ranging between 30% to 50%, I feel that dangers are being overweighted by the market. The corporate has a strong historical past of income and dividend development, even by tough occasions (Nice Monetary Disaster, pandemic). Moreover, the administration has pores and skin within the recreation and a confirmed trajectory of being too conservative when releasing estimates. Though the primary focus right this moment is decreasing debt, I don’t discard (nor do they, based on their newest earnings name) that they turn out to be extra aggressive with leverage and development if a superb alternative comes.
Catalysts:
- Decrease rates of interest
- Enchancment of European financial views
- Enchancment of S&P ranking (2026)
- Time
If no catalysts happen, I’m nonetheless pleased to be ready for the market to acknowledge the worth of an organization whereas receiving a 5.5% dividend yield and a web recurring earnings development of excessive single digit.
Dangers:
- Portfolio focus: Carrefour is a giant a part of the income.
- Debt: Though the corporate has traditionally had an occupancy fee near 100%, decreasing it to market requirements (about 95%, though it relies upon broadly on the regio) might imply difficulties in paying down the debt.
- Problem discovering new developments.
How do you see ARGAN? Do you discover the dividend and the potential development compelling?
I personal a place in ARGAN on the time of writing.
This communication is for info and schooling functions solely and shouldn’t be taken as funding recommendation, a private suggestion, or a suggestion of, or solicitation to purchase or promote, any monetary devices. This materials has been ready with out bearing in mind any specific recipient’s funding goals or monetary state of affairs, and has not been ready in accordance with the authorized and regulatory necessities to advertise unbiased analysis. Any references to previous or future efficiency of a monetary instrument, index or a packaged funding product aren’t, and shouldn’t be taken as, a dependable indicator of future outcomes. eToro makes no illustration and assumes no legal responsibility as to the accuracy or completeness of the content material of this publication.
