My Partner and I Can’t Agree on a Mattress. Will This $4,000 Beautyrest Bed Be the One?

Should you and your companion have totally different sleep preferences, that sleeping collectively generally is a nightmare at instances — and also you’re actually not alone. The Higher Sleep Council discovered that one in three People studies that their companion negatively impacts their sleep, and 63% of the {couples} surveyed spend many of the night time separated.

The idea of sleep divorce has turn into more and more fashionable as {couples} seek for options to their interrupted sleep, whether or not their companion snores or tosses and turns all night time. Dillon and I’ve had our fair proportion of struggles on this division. To be honest, neither of us is nice at getting strong relaxation. As gentle sleepers, we are inclined to wake one another up usually all through the night time — particularly when mendacity on a mattress that one among us finds uncomfortable.

Disclaimer: As companions, there is not any disgrace in accepting sleep divorce and sleeping in separate beds or bedrooms if that permits you each to get the very best relaxation attainable. Earlier than accepting sleep divorce as the ultimate resolution, we’re embarking on this bed-searching journey to see if we are able to discover one which works for each of us — and hopefully, our trials will aid you and your companion, too.

Dillon and I are members of CNET’s sleep staff. We analysis, check and evaluate mattresses and sleep-related merchandise for a dwelling. Sure, I do know. The irony is palpable. We’ve been on a mission to seek out the proper mattress to accommodate Dillon’s wants as a facet sleeper and my preferences as a abdomen sleeper. We’ve been attempting out totally different mattresses for 30 nights at a time and documenting the method alongside the way in which. To again up our claims in regards to the beds, we observe our sleep each night time to check our well being knowledge and sleep high quality.

This evaluate delves into our expertise sleeping on the Beautyrest Black Hybrid Collection Three (2024 Version). Final month, we have been on the Nectar Premier Hybrid. If you wish to study extra about that mattress — which was Dillon’s favourite — try our article evaluate and YouTube video.

So, does Beautyrest reside as much as its identify and assist us get the remaining we crave? Will we turn into extra stunning? Learn on to seek out out.

Video: We Slept on Beautyrest for 30 Nights

Watch us evaluate the Beautyrest Black Hybrid mattress on YouTube!

Preliminary ideas on the Beautyrest Black Hybrid mattress

The Simmons Bedding Firm has been round since 1870, and its flagship model, Beautyrest, bought its first mattress in 1925. Based mostly on the corporate’s historic influence alone, I used to be keen to check a Beautyrest mattress.

Dillon and I had comparable reactions once we first noticed the Beautyrest Black Hybrid at our mattress testing facility. We each beloved its smooth black look and the beautiful diamond cowl design. It is a particularly dense mattress, weighing almost 160 kilos for the queen-size. A mean queen-size mattress weighs wherever from 90 to 160 kilos, making it the heaviest mattress we have examined to date in our 30-night collection — which is just price noting in the event you transfer fairly a bit. Total, we have been impressed by how luxurious it regarded.

One other attribute we famous straight away was its plethora of handles to assist transfer and rotate the mattress. Although we do not suggest utilizing the handles to maneuver the complete weight of the mattress (they’ll rip or tear fairly simply), it does assist make the transferring course of a bit simpler — particularly for a dense mattress like this.

Firmness

Beautyrest provides a number of mattresses and firmness choices. We’ve the medium mannequin of the Beautyrest Black Hybrid Collection Three. The model claims this profile is right for all sleepers and those that “like a deeply contouring, responsive mattress with added conforming help and enhanced strain reduction.” 

Mendacity on the mattress for the primary time, Dillon and I agreed that it felt firmer than medium, leaning into medium-firm territory. Since my most popular sleeping place is on my abdomen, I used to be completely happy about this, as firmer beds provide extra help for holding the backbone aligned. As a facet sleeper, Dillon wasn’t certain it will be smooth sufficient for him — a operating theme we have seen all through our mattress-testing journey.

Temperature

We instantly seen that the quilt of this mattress felt cool to the contact. Beds with reminiscence foam usually sleep hotter as a result of the denser foam tends to entice and retain your physique warmth because it varieties round your curves. Beautyrest tries to fight this by including the “Sleep Local weather Floor” with cooling yarn and diamond particles infused into the reminiscence foam. Many mattress manufacturers declare their beds are cooling when usually they are not, in order two sizzling sleepers, we have been excited to check these options.

Really feel

Mendacity on the mattress for the primary time initially felt fairly agency and supportive. As I slowly started to sink into the layers, it softened up a bit, offering that body-conforming high quality of viscous reminiscence foam. After I acquired up, I seen that the supplies snapped again surprisingly quick at first after which extra slowly, seeming to supply a stability between dense and responsive. I used to be to see how it will truly really feel whereas sleeping on the mattress — would it not be predominately dense and reminiscence foamy? Would we be capable of change positions simply all through the night time, or would we really feel caught within the layers?

Our ideas on the finish of the trial

I totally loved my expertise sleeping on the Beautyrest Black Hybrid mattress. After a couple of nights of sleeping on Beautyrest, I wrote in my notes, “I like this mattress a lot. I don’t really feel like I’m overheating and don’t get up sore, even after sleeping on my facet. It is supportive for my again and abdomen.”

Firmness

Although the mannequin we examined is Beautyrest’s medium profile, it felt firmer than that — round medium-firm. This was confirmed by our fellow mattress reviewers and Mattress Smasher 9000, which scored the mattress at 7.5 out of 10 (extra on that beneath). 

Fortunately, Beautyrest provides a number of firmness choices for the Black Hybrid Collection Three, together with plush, medium and agency. Should you’re a facet sleeper, we suggest going with the plush model. Mixture sleepers on the lookout for extra help than strain reduction ought to go for the medium mannequin, whereas strict again and abdomen sleepers ought to try the medium or agency fashions. 

Regardless of the mattress being too agency for his liking, Dillon was getting surprisingly good relaxation — among the highest sleep scores he has had on this collection. His complete common sleep decreased by solely 4 minutes in comparison with Nectar. We anticipated his sleep numbers to drop way more than that, contemplating he could not spend as a lot time on his facet through the night time as he’d desire. The primary draw back is that he was spending extra time in gentle sleep versus deep sleep, and he snored extra on account of having to sleep on his again relatively than his facet. 

Learn extra: Anti-Loud night breathing Merchandise for a Peaceable Slumber

Really feel

Dillon and I beloved Beautyrest Black’s total really feel, as proven beneath by our matching scores of 18/20 for this class. It feels fairly agency at first however softens as your physique heats the froth, and you start to sink in slowly. It has a pleasing contouring sensation because the supplies mould round your curves, typical of dense reminiscence foam. Nevertheless, given the combo of micro coils, latex foam and a slight trace of pillow prime, it is not fairly as viscous as different reminiscence foam mattresses like Tempur-Pedic.

Factoring in its medium-firm profile, this mattress offers a bit extra push-back than you may count on, which I beloved as a abdomen sleeper. As stressed individuals, Dillon and I’ve discovered that reminiscence foam’s slight “caught” feeling helps stop us from tossing and turning all night time.

Building

It could appear apparent, however a mattress’s development informs its really feel, so let’s dive into the design. We like that this mattress is 15″ tall. Dillon and I desire the additional top provided by mattresses on the thicker facet, as they mechanically really feel extra luxurious — emulating that fascinating five-star lodge mattress really feel. The Beautyrest Black Hybrid is hefty however simply brief sufficient to not want deep-pocket sheets.

Hybrid design

This mattress’s main help system is a tall layer of individually wrapped coils, which offers enhanced sturdiness and breathability because it permits for extra airflow. On prime of that could be a layer of micro coils, which improves the mattress’s movement isolation. This hybrid design additionally means it will possibly stand up to fairly a little bit of weight and strain, making it appropriate for all physique varieties, together with heavier people and {couples}.

Temperature regulation

Above the micro coils is what the model calls “Micro Diamond Reminiscence Foam,” supposed to maintain you cooler by drawing warmth away out of your physique. Pairing that with the “Sleep Local weather Floor” of the quilt (which additionally has the micro diamonds), this mattress has spectacular cooling capabilities — particularly given its reminiscence foam design.

Usually, beds with dense reminiscence foam sleep hotter as the froth surrounds you and retains your physique warmth, however the Beautyrest Black Hybrid does an incredible job of stopping this. I believed I might really feel a lot hotter on this mattress than I did. I would not say it was overly cooling, however we slept temperature-neutral and hardly felt heat — which is superior since Dillon and I are fairly sizzling sleepers.

Foams

This mattress’s strain reduction comes primarily from Beautyrest’s “ContourFit Type HD Materials,” a elaborate method of claiming consolation foam. This layer cradles your curves and joints, whereas the supportive latex layer offers a responsive bounce-back sensation. Beautyrest’s foams are CertiPur-US licensed, which means they’re made with out harsh chemical substances, formaldehyde or heavy metals. Whereas it is changing into the trade normal amongst mattress manufacturers, we admire that Beautyrest’s beds have this certification. 

Movement isolation

Due to the dense reminiscence foam really feel (and that additional layer of micro coils), we thought this mattress carried out properly relating to movement isolation. I hardly felt Dillon switching positions. Most significantly, I not often seen our cat leaping on or up and doing or taking a shower subsequent to my head — which is a reasonably spectacular feat. Dillon additionally seldom felt me transferring round (except I used to be actively kicking him in my sleep, which allegedly occurred a couple of instances). 

Should you’re a light-weight sleeper sharing the mattress with a companion, having one with good motion-isolating capabilities is an efficient attribute to search for, and this one handed the check.

Edge help

Sturdy edge help is one other attribute to search for in the event you share the mattress with a companion (or youngsters or pets). The Beautyrest Black Hybrid has some strong edges. We not often felt like we have been going to fall off, and there is not a lot sagging in the event you’re mendacity or sitting on the sting. Nevertheless, I did not discover it fairly as supportive as a couple of different beds we have examined — just like the Avocado Luxurious Natural mattress, which boasts bolstered metal across the perimeter.

Scoring the Beautyrest Black Hybrid mattress

At CNET, our sleep consultants use an goal, standardized system to attain mattresses. For this 30-night collection, Dillon and I created a personalized system to subjectively charge the options and qualities we search in a mattress. Really feel and firmness are scored out of 20 factors, whereas the opposite traits are scored out of 10 for a complete attainable rating of 100. We rated these components preferentially, which means what we favored or didn’t like on a private stage. 

Learn extra: How CNET Exams Mattresses

After finishing the 30-night trial, Dillon and I rated every attribute and provided a quick clarification. Here’s a breakdown of our closing scores.

Dillon’s scoring breakdown

• Firmness: 12/20
  I may get by on this mattress. Nevertheless, the firmness retains me from my most popular facet sleeping place and forces me to sleep on my again and abdomen, so I’ve to knock off a couple of factors.
• Really feel: 18/20
  I like the general really feel. This mattress has a denser really feel than Nectar Premier, the final mattress we have been on. That mattress had a lighter and extra ethereal reminiscence foam really feel, whereas this has extra of that historically dense reminiscence foam really feel, which I nonetheless actually like.
• Movement isolation: 10/10
  This mattress has tremendous nice movement isolation. I’m giving it 10/10. I solely felt Aly transfer when she was kicking me in her sleep.
• Edge help: 8/10
  I by no means felt like I might fall off the facet, despite the fact that I sleep on the sting fairly a bit. There may be strong edge help.
• Temperature: 7/10
  I didn’t essentially really feel just like the mattress was actively cooling by way of the sheets, however I additionally by no means overheated. It retains you temperature-regulated.
• Building/design: 10/10
  It’s acquired coils. It’s acquired micro coils. It’s acquired latex foam. It’s acquired reminiscence foam. It is acquired a bit pillow-top really feel. The Beautyrest Black Hybrid is undeniably luxurious and high-quality.
• Model insurance policies: 5/10
  The trial interval is the baseline for mattress manufacturers. I wish to see a extra prolonged trial interval. I admire the free returns and white glove supply. The value is on the costly facet, even for a way luxurious it’s. I don’t see many individuals eager to pay that a lot, however I do assume it could possibly be price it.
• Sleep high quality: 8/10
  I can’t argue with the numbers. I slept virtually as properly on Nectar (simply 4 minutes much less on common). Nevertheless, I did spend extra time loud night breathing on Beautyrest as a result of I needed to lie on my again, and it was too agency to remain on my facet lengthy. 

Dillon’s total rating: 7.8/10

“This can be a premium, luxurious choice that I believe many {couples} shall be proud of (so long as you’re OK with sleeping primarily in your again or abdomen). The movement isolation and edge help are top-notch. The one different factor to fret about is the value, however you positively get what you pay for,” Dillon defined.

Aly’s scoring breakdown

• Firmness: 18/20
  It’s virtually my excellent firmness stage. I want it have been a tad firmer for my abdomen and again, however on my facet, it’s nice.
• Really feel: 18/20
  I like the texture of this mattress. It has a dense reminiscence foam really feel, the place you’re feeling your self settling into it for some time. Nevertheless, due to its layer of bouncy latex foam, it is a hair extra responsive than your typical reminiscence foam mattress. It is very supportive.
• Movement isolation: 9/10
  The movement isolation is great. I hardly felt Dillon transferring when switching positions and barely felt when Jess (our cat) jumped on and off.
• Edge help: 7/10
  The sting help is nice. I by no means actually felt like I used to be going to fly off the sting, however I additionally did not spend a ton of time on the perimeter.
• Temperature: 7/10
  Reminiscence foam sleeps sizzling as a result of the dense foam retains your physique warmth as you sink in, and it conforms round you. Beautyrest’s foam being infused with micro-diamonds does assist a bit, but it surely’s not overly cooling if you’ve been mendacity on it for some time. I did really feel a bit heat at instances.
• Building/design: 10/10
  I truthfully don’t know what I might change to enhance the development — perhaps a bolstered perimeter. I like the way it appears to be like with the smooth black cowl and diamond design on prime. It principally has all the pieces you’d need in a hybrid reminiscence foam mattress.
• Insurance policies: 6/10
  The insurance policies are effective, but it surely’s expensive. Environmental sustainability is essential to me, and Beautyrest is actually striving for that—the beds have recycled metal, CertiPur US-certified foams, and so forth., and the model provides a mattress recycling program, which I admire.
• Sleep high quality: 8/10
  My sleep high quality was fairly good. It elevated considerably from the final mattress we have been on, however I nonetheless have but to hit the 8-hour common I hoped for.

Aly’s total rating: 8.3/10

How we tracked our sleep

Dillon used his Apple Watch to trace his sleep, and I used my Whoop band. They supplied comparable well being knowledge and sleep metrics, permitting us to check our total sleep high quality with the earlier beds we have reviewed on this collection.

The first knowledge we centered on for this trial included our sleep levels, particularly how lengthy we spent in gentle/core sleep, REM, deep sleep and time awake.

Learn extra: 8 Greatest Sleep Trackers for 2025

Our sleep high quality on the Beautyrest Black Hybrid

We acknowledge that different components have an effect on sleep high quality apart from our mattress — from the cat bathing subsequent to my head on the witching hour to our food plan, train, stress ranges, caffeine consumption and extra. We maintain our bed room setting just about the identical each night time: similar bedding, air temperature, sound machine and darkness ranges. We strive sticking to a constant daytime schedule and bedtime routine. We’re not excellent check rats, however we do our greatest. 

Monitoring our sleep for 30 nights additionally offers a common image of our sleep high quality and whether or not it improved or declined on that individual mattress.

Whole sleep averages

Let’s get right down to the nitty-gritty. As proven within the graph beneath, Dillon’s complete sleep common decreased ever so barely from 7:27 hours (7.45) on Nectar to 7:23 hours (7.38) on Beautyrest. We have been shocked that his complete sleep common stayed almost the identical, given the truth that Beautyrest was a bit too agency for him to sleep comfortably on his facet. 

I used to be happy with my outcomes when analyzing our knowledge after the 30 nights. My complete common sleep elevated fairly a bit from 6:59 hours (6.98) on Nectar to 7:31 hours (7.52) on Beautyrest — a bounce of 32 minutes.

Sleep levels

Under is a visible breakdown of our time spent within the numerous sleep levels. I spent extra time in deep sleep, whereas Dillon spent extra in gentle sleep. This is sensible on condition that I used to be comfy in any sleep place, particularly my abdomen, which I spend more often than not in.

Dillon spent extra time within the REM (fast eye motion) stage than I did, which additionally is sensible. Since he spent extra time in gentle sleep than deep sleep, his mind might have prioritized REM sleep, generally known as REM rebound. The REM stage is essential for forming long-term recollections, processing feelings and supporting cognitive growth. Whenever you’re not getting sufficient high quality sleep or are sleep-deprived, your mind will shorten different levels of sleep to remain in REM longer.

Right here, you may see Dillon’s restorative sleep was a lot much less on Beautyrest — from 1:20 hours (1.33) of deep sleep on Nectar to 0:49 hours (0.82) on Beautyrest. His common REM sleep decreased from 1:49 hours (1.82) on Nectar to 1:31 hours (1.52) on Beautyrest.

My restorative sleep flip-flopped. My quantity of deep sleep elevated fairly a bit, going from 1:13 (hours (1.22) on Nectar to 1:51 hours (1.85) on Beautyrest — a much-welcomed change. 

Conversely, my REM sleep decreased from 1:32 hours (1.53) on Nectar to 1:11 hours (1.18) on Beautyrest.

Dillon and I each spent almost an hour awake every night time. It is regular to get up for transient intervals all through the night time, generally known as “disturbances” or “arousals,” however they typically solely final a couple of minutes, and it’s possible you’ll not even pay attention to it. Dillon and I nonetheless spend fairly a little bit of absolutely acutely aware time awake all through the night time, which we’re working to resolve.

Smashing the Beautyrest Black Hybrid mattress

Our proprietary Mattress Smasher 9000 (MS9K) equipment, created by CNET Labs engineers, finds any mattress’s goal firmness stage. We positioned Beautyrest on the bottom body, activated the gadget’s customized software program program and watched this distinctive CNET-only know-how do its factor. 

After operating the mattress by way of the Mattress Smasher a couple of instances, the Beautyrest Black Hybrid Collection Three’s closing goal stage was 7.5 out of 10 — a bit greater than we anticipated.

Be taught extra: Utilizing Tech to Take a look at Beds: Say Good day to Our Mattress Smasher 9000

Model insurance policies: transport, trial interval and guarantee

Beautyrest provides a 100-night trial interval and a 10-year guarantee. These insurance policies aren’t as spectacular as these of different manufacturers providing 365-night trials or lifetime warranties, however 100 nights ought to nonetheless be sufficient time to determine if the mattress is best for you. 

Given its hefty development and hybrid design, this mattress ought to positively last as long as ten years or longer if correctly cared for.

Along with free transport and returns, Beautyrest provides white glove supply and free mattress elimination. That is an superior service to reap the benefits of in the event you aren’t certain what to do along with your previous mattress.

Be taught extra: Don’t Toss Your Mattress. Right here Are Eco-Pleasant Options

Beautyrest beds could be discovered at numerous mattress retailers and furnishings shops that carry the Simmons model. Should you’re fascinated about Beautyrest however need to check out some mattresses earlier than shopping for outright, try Beautyrest’s retailer finder to discover a location close to you. 

What we discovered and what’s subsequent

The historical past of Beautyrest

I discovered the backstory of this mattress fascinating, so I needed to share a quick overview. The Beautyrest mattress was first launched a century in the past, and its dad or mum firm has been making waves within the trade for for much longer. The Simmons Bedding Firm was based in 1870 by Zalmon G. Simmons, later changing into the primary producer to mass-produce metal wire mattresses. By 1889, the Simmons Manufacturing Firm had refined its bed-making course of sufficient to drop the typical worth of a mattress from $12 to 95 cents for customers, making them reasonably priced for everybody.

The founder’s son, Zalmon Simmons Jr., went on to create and promote the primary Beautyrest mattress in 1925, that includes Simmons’ patented Pocketed Coil know-how. This premium mattress was dearer, retailing for $39.50 on the time (valued at round $720 at the moment). The corporate used an progressive marketing campaign that includes testimonials from “celebrities” like Henry Ford, Eleanor Roosevelt and Thomas Edison to promote. This profitable advertising and marketing tactic generated an estimated $9 million in gross sales by 1929.

The Simmons Firm additionally first developed king and queen beds. Previous to this, most mattresses have been both twins or doubles. To at the present time, Beautyrest is the model’s signature mattress and one of the vital well-known within the trade.

Pricing

The Beautyrest Black Hybrid isn’t what we might think about an reasonably priced mattress at the moment. At $4,000 for a queen dimension, it’s properly out of our funds — and if we hadn’t had the chance to check this mattress by way of CNET, Dillon and I might in all probability not have thought of it. That stated, this mattress is actually luxurious. The Beautyrest Black Hybrid could possibly be definitely worth the funding in the event you’re out there for a high-end mattress like this, and it checks all of your containers. I don’t doubt this mattress will provide supportive, contouring consolation for a decade or longer if correctly cared for. 

Moreover, Beautyrest often provides this mattress at a reduction. Proper now, it is $600 off, bringing the value for a queen right down to $3,400.

Firmness

I do spend a while on my facet at night time, so I believed I’d get away with a medium to medium-soft mattress since that is what Dillon prefers. That led us to strive the Nectar Premier Hybrid final month, the place I struggled to get comfy and felt like my backbone did not have sufficient help. It confirmed the notion that it was just too smooth for me. Sleeping on this Beautyrest mattress, which lands round medium-firm, solidified that I would like a firmer mattress. I used to be way more comfy on this mattress and felt supported throughout.

The other rings true for Dillon — as a facet sleeper, he was extra comfy on the softer Nectar than the firmer Beautyrest (although we have been a lot nearer to agreeing on this mattress than any on this collection to date). Although Beautyrest was dang shut, we nonetheless haven’t discovered the “excellent” mattress for us each.

Subsequent, we’ll check the Sleep Quantity ClimateCool mattress. This good mattress has adjustable firmness and temperature management on either side, permitting Dillon and me to have personalised settings for every of us. Will or not it’s sufficient? Keep tuned to seek out out.

Who ought to get the Beautyrest Black Hybrid mattress?

This mattress may be for you if:

• You’ve gotten the funds for it
• You like the dense reminiscence foam really feel 
• You search a supportive hybrid mattress
• You’re a again or abdomen sleeper (or a heavier mixture sleeper)
• You need a reminiscence foam mattress that gained’t overheat

It is best to in all probability skip this mattress if:

• You don’t like the texture of reminiscence foam
• It’s not inside your funds 
• You need an all-foam mattress 
• You’re a strict facet sleeper (if that’s the case, go for the plush model)