Gender quotas and inclusion necessities: are they only a window-dressing instrument or a driver of actual change? For many years, the finance trade worldwide has been predominantly male, with Lebanon’s monetary sector reflecting comparable developments. Regardless of developments, many ladies in Lebanon nonetheless discover themselves excluded from the trade’s “cigar lounge”—the unique, casual arenas the place pivotal selections are typically made, networks are solid, and management roles are sometimes assigned. Although ladies’s participation in Lebanese finance is rising, their illustration in management positions stays restricted. Whereas Lebanon’s monetary disaster has been harsh on ladies, it additionally gave sure finance leaders the prospect to notice that in comparison with their male counterparts, ladies are sometimes extra resilient and dependable in instances of disaster.
Slowly shifting statistics
Whereas ladies represent a good portion of the banking workforce, management roles are nonetheless predominantly occupied by males. “Life has taken me from one factor to a different. I initially joined as an worker, however over time, I carved out my very own area. It wasn’t given to me—I needed to battle for it,” says Hasmig Khoury, a Company Social Accountability (CSR) Strategist and member of Lebanon’s Financial and Social Council. Khoury, who spent 15 years at Financial institution Audi organising and main the CSR unit, witnessed and contributed to the sector’s transformation. She emphasizes that management alternatives for girls, whereas rising, are nonetheless not evenly distributed.
In accordance with Nada Rizkallah, a senior government and head of danger administration at Credit score Libanais, ladies in Lebanon’s banking sector as soon as outnumbered males at 57 p.c however had been primarily concentrated in center administration or operational roles. “We had been at all times current,” she famous, “however by no means actually in energy.”
This phenomenon just isn’t distinctive to Lebanon. In accordance with a 2021 report on gender variety within the monetary providers trade by Deloitte International, an advisory and analysis agency, ladies maintain 21 p.c of board seats, 19 p.c of C-suite roles, and a mere 5 p.c of CEO positions inside monetary service establishments globally. In the US, ladies occupy 21.2 p.c of C-suite positions throughout the monetary providers sector, underscoring the worldwide nature of this disparity.
In Lebanon, some ladies imagine that is altering for the higher. Maya El Kadi, Deputy CEO and Head of Funding Banking at BlomInvest, after spending 30 years at Blom financial institution, emphasised that her ascent to management was facilitated by robust mentorship. El Kadi’s profession trajectory has been marked by many constructive moments, and he or she mirrored on how she has skilled a piece tradition that fosters gender equality. “I had an excellent sponsor and mentor throughout the financial institution. Anyone I began working with, it’s a person, not a lady, however who actually gave me a whole lot of alternatives. And in a method, because of this I attempt to replicate that with individuals I work with, however largely with ladies,” she recounted.
Ladies have proved to be the drivers of systematic change, together with in areas associated to CSR. Quite a few research have proven that female-led corporations have greater worker satisfaction, retention charges, and innovation. This contribution to a more healthy tradition within the office extends outward to areas of CSR. Ladies be sure that their companies shift their priorities in terms of making an impression on the neighborhood and the market. A 2024 research by the Worldwide Journal of Company Social Accountability discovered that larger gender equality on the board stage led to higher CSR efficiency and workplaces that centered “compassion, kindness, helpfulness, empathy, interpersonal sensitivity, a willingness to nurture, and a larger concern for others’ well-being.”
Khoury’s key position in establishing CSR initiatives inside Financial institution Audi demonstrates how ladies in management push for extra sustainable and moral enterprise practices. “We rocked the boat in getting individuals on board with environmental and social impression.” Khoury not directly touched on the systemic obstacles ladies face in finance, notably when attempting to maneuver past mid-management roles. “At first, CSR was simply seen as a human sources factor, one thing on the aspect. Nevertheless, as soon as the management realized its actual impression, I began reporting to the overall administration. That’s when the doorways began opening.”This perception underscores how ladies’s management is commonly undermined till it proves indispensable, echoing the struggles of different ladies in finance. Furthermore, El Kadi helps the concept ladies leaders can shift views and management methods, “I believe having extra feminine management roles will convey quite a bit to the desk. Any variety does. And I believe ladies, in that sense, have a look at issues in another way” she says.
Are casual areas nonetheless a “boy’s membership”?
Cultural and social norms proceed to affect office dynamics in Lebanon. Deep-seated biases persist, even inside establishments that profess gender neutrality. For instance, gender-based unequal pay is often justified with the notion that ladies don’t want the identical earnings since they aren’t the primary breadwinners within the household, a reasoning that emerges from the deep-seated patriarchal tradition that burdens males with provisional roles throughout the household construction. Thus, the gender wage hole in Lebanon is to the drawback of girls—they earn 22 p.c lower than males—after controlling for elements corresponding to schooling and job choice as talked about in a 2022 report by the World Financial institution.
Moreover, casual decision-making areas—corresponding to unique enterprise dinners or closed-door boardroom discussions—usually exclude ladies. “It’s not nearly getting the job,” Rizkallah says, “It’s in regards to the conversations that occur after hours, in locations we’re not invited to.” Khoury agrees with the thought of casual decision-making areas and the way company cultures could be exclusionary: “In banking, the true selections aren’t made in boardrooms.” Globally, ladies stay underrepresented at high ranges, struggling to achieve equality in alternatives to ascend.
When it comes to entrepreneurship, the World Financial institution report signifies that solely 11 p.c of girls are self-employed entrepreneurs, in comparison with 25 p.c of males, and simply 5 p.c of small companies, 5 p.c of medium-sized companies, and 25 p.c of enormous companies in Lebanon are led by ladies. As well as, solely 6 p.c of companies managed by males have ladies among the many homeowners, in comparison with 76 p.c of female-led companies that even have feminine possession.
Furthermore, Rizkallah mirrored on the bias ladies face throughout recruitment and promotions, particularly in terms of marital standing and motherhood: “You don’t know what number of instances I’ve been requested in interviews: ‘Are you married? Are you getting married?’ I even used to ask the identical query.” This highlights how systemic gender discrimination continues to have an effect on hiring and profession development in Lebanon’s finance sector. Rizkallah then identified that over the course of her profession, she discovered that it was her feminine workers—married and single alike—who proved to be extra loyal to the corporate and who had been extra expert at navigating crises.
Methods for Survival: Enjoying the Recreation or Altering the Guidelines?
Ladies in Lebanon’s monetary sector have developed numerous methods to navigate office challenges. Some have leveraged their gender to their benefit, utilizing diplomacy and negotiation expertise to realize allies in male-dominated areas.
Others, like El Kadi, advocate for a merit-based method, believing that demonstrating competence is one of the simplest ways to problem stereotypes. “When you’ve ladies in management positions, you give position fashions to youthful women. You additionally give males the assumption that they [the women] can do in addition to they do, if no more” she says. But, at the same time as ladies excel, the burden of regularly proving themselves persists. Furthermore, ladies are likely to morph their habits to suit the expectations within the office:” I don’t settle for to see a lady crying on the office. It’s refined, but when we would like equality, we’ve to behave prefer it.” Rizkallah says. This reveals the necessity to undertake a persona stereotypically thought of extra “masculine,” shying away from any habits that may be deemed as a weak point and aligning with stereotyped traits attributed to ladies. This intuition goes towards proof that women-led corporations have more healthy work cultures, indicating that bringing extra care into work is nice for corporations.
El Kadi emphasizes the significance of ethical encouragement by saying “If I need to give recommendation to ladies within the office, I’d inform them that you need to get up for your self. It’s a must to know your worth. No person will see your worth higher than you do.” Though emotional intelligence and assist roles usually change into an unpaid, gendered burden on ladies within the office, the adverse “emotional” trait given to ladies now reveals energy. Having the emotional intelligence and capability to see past short-term revenue targets allowed for a extra sustainable and people-centered method in management positions.
Moreover, ladies got roles and obligations that weren’t on the high precedence lists of firm targets. As Khoury famous, “Even in the present day, CSR is seen as ‘comfortable work’—and guess who will get assigned to the ‘comfortable’ stuff? Ladies,” she provides.This reinforces how ladies in finance are sometimes pigeonholed into roles seen as non-essential, limiting their possibilities of rising to CEO or C-suite positions.
Crises as catalysts
Lebanon’s monetary disaster has had a paradoxical impact on ladies’s roles in finance. With many males emigrating for higher alternatives, extra ladies have stepped into management roles out of necessity. “It wasn’t a gender revolution,” Rizkallah defined. “It was survival. Males left, and we needed to step up. Furthermore, the working ladies held the highlight as they proved extra environment friendly in dealing with crises.” Rizakallah goes on to say: “Through the monetary collapse, ladies confirmed extra resilience. They had been higher at dealing with crises as a result of they’ve at all times needed to multitask and adapt.” Nevertheless, this shift just isn’t with out challenges. The monetary instability has additionally compelled many ladies to go away the workforce, notably those that might not afford home assist or needed to relocate with their households.
Khoury identified that systemic change is just attainable via institutional reforms and dedication from management. “We have to cease treating ladies’s success tales as exceptions. They need to be the norm,” she says. Whereas it’s legitimate for some ladies to get consideration for his or her success tales, this consideration shouldn’t be primarily based on gender; numerous ladies succeed day by day, and it’s no exception.
Most ladies leaders agree with the gender quota, although it could be seen as favoritism or compelled, nonetheless, it’s proven to permit high administration to contemplate feminine professionals when it was not the case earlier than. This perception ties again to the article’s argument that gender equality in finance must be structurally enforced, not simply left to particular person resilience. When requested whether or not CSR in banking had died out post-crisis, Khoury states that: “[It is] not a graveyard, however a bench. We’ve been sidelined, however we’re not out.” This metaphor captures how ladies in finance are sometimes the primary to be sidelined throughout monetary crises, even when they performed an important position in stabilizing the sector.
Opening the doorways for the following technology
Whereas progress is obvious, systemic change is required to make sure that ladies in finance obtain equal alternatives. Interviewees advocate for coverage reforms, together with obligatory gender quotas in boardrooms, equal pay enforcement, and larger work-life stability assist. The inclusion of girls within the workforce can yield a number of advantages for the Lebanese economic system. For instance, the World Financial institution report states that closing the gender hole within the workforce might improve Lebanon’s GDP by 9 p.c, demonstrating the numerous financial potential of empowering ladies in finance.
Schooling additionally performs a vital position in shifting mindsets. A number of ladies highlighted the significance of addressing gender bias from an early age, noting how societal conditioning begins in childhood. It’s not nearly finance; It’s about instructing assertiveness and elevating women to know they deserve a seat on the desk—and boys to see them as equals.
The finance sector in Lebanon stays a difficult panorama for girls, but the tales of these breaking obstacles supply hope for the long run, particularly when in comparison with company tradition in different Center Japanese nations. Nevertheless, structural and cultural obstacles proceed to hinder ladies’s full participation in Lebanon’s finance trade. Whereas financial crises have pushed extra ladies into management roles, they’re usually stepping in out of necessity slightly than structural inclusion. Extra proactive insurance policies—corresponding to gender quotas in company boards, authorized enforcement of equal pay, and monetary inclusion packages—are wanted to create actual, sustainable change in Lebanon’s monetary sector. As El Kadi put it, “In the event that they gained’t allow us to into the cigar lounge, we’ll construct our personal area.”
DONATE NOW
