What was claimed
A complete of 105,000 asylum seekers have entered Australia since Labor took authorities in Could 2022.
Our verdict
False. The determine pertains to folks with failed or pending asylum purposes. Most entered Australia below the earlier Coalition authorities.
Opposition Chief Peter Dutton has attacked Labor’s immigration report, claiming 105,000 asylum seekers have entered Australia since Anthony Albanese’s authorities was elected.
That is false. The 105,000 determine pertains to the variety of asylum seekers in Australia on the finish of August 2023. Most have been already within the nation on the time of the Could 2022 federal election. The vast majority of asylum seekers presently residing in Australia arrived through the 2013-2022 Coalition authorities.
Get Crikey FREE to your inbox each weekday morning with the Crikey Worm.
Dutton made the declare a number of instances throughout an interview in Western Australia on October 4.
“Labor’s presided over 105,000 asylum seekers over the course of the final 15 months — a report quantity in our nation,” he stated.
“You’ve acquired 105,000 asylum seekers which have are available on (Albanese’s) watch.”
The opposition chief was answering questions on immigration following the discharge of the Nixon overview, a Labor-commissioned inquiry into the alleged exploitation of Australia’s visa system.
His feedback about 105,000 asylum seekers coming to Australia below Labor have been reported in The Sydney Morning Herald, Guardian Australia and The Australian Monetary Assessment, although all three media shops identified the inaccuracy of Dutton’s declare.
AAP FactCheck requested Dutton’s workplace for the premise of his declare however didn’t obtain a response.
The Division of Dwelling Affairs publishes detailed statistics on visa purposes, immigration and asylum seeker claims. The determine on the centre of the declare pertains to purposes for subclass 866 visas, in any other case often called everlasting onshore safety visas.
The division describes the subclass 866 visa as being “for individuals who arrived in Australia on a sound visa and need to search asylum”. The visa is solely out there to folks already in Australia who cleared immigration after they first arrived.
Asylum seekers supplied a subclass 866 visa can keep in Australia completely so long as they meet different necessities, the division says.
The Refugee Council of Australia says it takes a median of greater than two years for an onshore safety visa utility to succeed in an preliminary resolution by the division. Rejected purposes can take 10 years or extra to undergo the total attraction and judicial overview course of, the council says.
Asylum will also be claimed by individuals who arrive by sea, which the division refers to as “unauthorised maritime arrivals” (UMAs). Nevertheless, for the needs of this fact-check, all figures refer solely to subclass 866 onshore safety visas, which was the topic of Dutton’s declare.
The division publishes month-to-month statistics about subclass 866 visas as a part of its humanitarian program dataset.
That information exhibits 29,246 folks in Australia have been ready for a call on their subclass 866 visa utility in August 2023, the latest figures out there on the time of writing (web page 4). An extra 75,430 folks had been refused a visa however remained in Australia and have been “but to be deported”, the figures present.
Including the 2 classes collectively makes a complete of 104,676 asylum seekers both awaiting an final result for his or her visa request or who already had their utility refused. By comparability, the info for Could 2022, the month Labor was elected to authorities, exhibits 94,260 asylum seekers in Australia have been both ready for a visa resolution or already had an utility refused.
Due to this fact, the variety of asylum seekers has elevated by about 10,400 folks below Labor, when in comparison with Could 2022. By these measures, it’s clear Mr Dutton’s declare is incorrect as most asylum seekers have been already within the nation by the point Labor got here to energy.
Nevertheless, Affiliate Professor Daniel Ghezelbash from UNSW Sydney’s Kaldor Centre for Worldwide Refugee Legislation instructed AAP FactCheck it was not doable to say precisely when these asylum seekers entered the nation.
“None of those folks truly arrived as asylum seekers. All of them got here by means of different visa pathways,” Dr Ghezelbash stated.
Dr Ghezelbash stated as a result of the visa was solely open to individuals who had already handed by means of immigration, it was uncommon for a safety declare to be lodged at an airport.
“It’s way more possible they’ve frolicked residing locally on one other legitimate visa for some time period. It may be anyplace from a number of months to a few years.”
It was possible the overwhelming majority of the 94,260 asylum seekers already within the nation on the time of the Could 2022 election entered Australia through the earlier 9 years of Coalition authorities, Dr Ghezelbash stated.
The info exhibits 23,882 new subclass 866 visa purposes have been lodged within the first 15 full months of the Labor authorities (June 2022 to August 2023 inclusive). Due to this fact, 23,882 is the utmost doable variety of present asylum seekers who entered Australia throughout that interval.
Nevertheless, it’s unimaginable to say how many individuals who entered the nation previously 15 months will declare asylum sooner or later sooner or later.
AAP FactCheck’s evaluation of the info discovered an approval charge of round 13% for subclass 866 visas.
This takes under consideration the whole variety of visa purposes between September 2021 to August 2023 and the whole variety of approvals. Nevertheless, it’s not doable to find out whether or not the approvals relate to the visa purposes for a similar interval.
New purposes have averaged about 1300 every month over the identical time interval, although the amount of month-to-month lodgements has elevated considerably for the reason that 2022 federal election.
Labor has responded to the Nixon overview by pledging nearly $160 million of further assets to assist pace up visa processing.
The decision
Peter Dutton’s declare Labor has overseen 105,000 asylum seekers getting into Australia is fake.
The determine refers back to the 104,676 asylum seekers within the nation as of August 2023. It doesn’t discuss with newly arrived asylum seekers, as prompt by Dutton.
Most of these 104,676 folks have been already within the nation by the point Labor got here to energy in Could 2022.
Nevertheless, as a result of onshore safety visas are solely out there to individuals who enter the nation with a sound visa, it’s unimaginable to say precisely what number of asylum seekers got here to Australia throughout any given interval.
False. The declare is inaccurate.
