Identical, properly… most likely no less than. Purchased my first and was very happy. Appears to be like, feels, and performs like a really good controller. About 11 months in I received a separating grip, a sticky bumper, and a dangling/catching set off. Received my guarantee substitute and am about 4 months into the 2nd one. Have already instructed myself if this one does not final a yr then I am achieved. I will discover one other model with paddles. About $200 for a controller that hardly lasts a yr is simply not a suitable product. It is too dangerous, I am really pretty loyal and proud of my general 11+ yr expertise as a Microsoft buyer, however not on this occasion.