For those who’re on Twitter, you have most likely seen a LOT of chatter about Lizzo’s latest live performance during which she performed a 200-year-old flute that was gifted to James Madison, a founding father. The star posted a clip of the second with the flute on stage, proven under:
NOBODY HAS EVER HEARD THIS FAMOUS CRYSTAL FLUTE BEFORE
NOW YOU HAVE
IM THE FIRST & ONLY PERSON TO EVER PLAY THIS PRESIDENTIAL 200-YEAR-OLD CRYSTAL FLUTE— THANK YOU @librarycongress ❤️
Lizzo
The flute was given to the previous president in 1813 as a celebratory reward for his second inauguration. Weirdly sufficient, Madison himself by no means performed it — after it was granted to him, the flute was despatched to the archives on the Library of Congress, and it has been sitting there for alllll this time. That’s, till this week, when Lizzo was invited to “come see it and even play a pair” of songs.
The @librarycongress has the most important flute assortment on the earth with greater than 1,800. It incl Pres James Madison’s 1813 crystal flute.
@lizzo we’d love so that you can come see it and even play a pair if you find yourself in DC subsequent week. Like your track they’re “Good as hell.”😉
Carla Hayden
Librarian of Congress Carla Hayden — who’s the primary Black lady to guide the nationwide library — advised BuzzFeed Information she was “thrilled” about Lizzo taking part in the flute and that she was in a position to assist make it occur.
In case you did not know, Lizzo is definitely a classically educated flutist, so it makes excellent sense that she can be invited to offer the flute a whirl.
Earlier than her live performance, Lizzo practiced a couple of songs on the Library, which has the most important flute assortment on the earth. A video of the apply session was posted on Twitter, as proven under:
A flute @lizzo performed within the Essential Studying Room Monday (with permission from some fortunate researchers who had been there!) seems to be much like the crystal one she had at her live performance, however is definitely plexiglass. It is usually very uncommon & was manufactured when the fabric was first invented.🔊
Library of Congress
As you possibly can most likely guess, some folks — largely conservatives — on Twitter weren’t too comfortable concerning the centuries-old flute being performed.
This Lizzo-flute controversy is an ideal instance of what I’ve termed Face Tattoo Phenomenon™: the phenomenon whereby somebody does one thing intentionally controversial in an try to attract consideration, after which acts offended if you discover.
Somebody who recognized themselves as “President Trump’s favourite writer” tried to say that Lizzo “is not proficient sufficient.”
Lizzo is not proficient sufficient to play music on a $20 Yamaha Plastic Recorder off Amazon not to mention a crystal flute as soon as owned by James Madison.
The Biden Administration is making a mockery of the nation.
One different particular person even went so far as to say that the flute-playing “degrade[d] our historical past.”
The Library of Congress actually took out a 200-year outdated flute that belonged to James Madison simply so Lizzo may twerk with it.
They degrade our historical past after which name you racist for those who truly worth it. https://t.co/i5cHjl5RXX
Nevertheless, there have been many others who identified the racist undertones of the criticism.
Lizzo is such an attention-grabbing particular person for proper wing content material creators to moralize about as a result of she’s so squeaky clear. She makes catchy songs about positivity and performs the flute. There’s no believable deniability that they hate her for some other cause than being black and fats.
Individuals make clear how flawed right-wing Twitter was of their takes on the matter.
For those who wouldn’t have an issue with Taylor Swift taking part in Ben Franklin’s piano, you shouldn’t have an issue with Lizzo taking part in James Madison’s flute.
For those who do have an issue, cease and take into consideration why that’s.
And one particular person introduced up one other salient level — did y’all even know this flute existed earlier than Lizzo performed it???
Fabulous famous person singer Lizzo resides rent-free within the empty minds of racists right this moment for masterfully taking part in a 200 12 months outdated crystal flute they by no means even knew existed till she performed it. Should be exhausting to stay with such hate day in and time out.
Another person subverted the feedback by saying they thought Lizzo must be forged as a mermaid in her personal film. Speaking to you, Hollywood!
Personally I feel Lizzo must be in a film the place she’s an attractive flute-playing mermaid who lures sailors to their watery doom
And at last, one other particular person spotlighted the truth that Lizzo taking part in this flute was a second of historical past being made, since James Madison was the proposer of the three-fifths compromise.
James Madison was the writer of the three/5 compromise. He’s fortunate @lizzo didn’t break that flute into 5 items and throw it off the stage. Keep mad.
So, yeah. Lizzo did that.
What do you suppose? Let me know within the feedback.
