A number of elements can have an effect on whether or not toxins inside loss of life cap mushrooms kill those that devour them, Erin Patterson’s triple-murder trial has been instructed.
This consists of the individual’s age, weight, their tolerance to the mushroom’s poison and the quantity that they devour, toxicologist Dimitri Gerostamoulos instructed a Supreme Courtroom jury in regional Victoria right this moment.
Patterson, 50, has reached the mid-way level of a trial the place she is accused of murdering three of her estranged husband’s members of the family by intentionally poisoning them with a beef Wellington.
She has pleaded not responsible to 3 counts of homicide and certainly one of tried homicide over the July 2023 meal which led to the deaths of Don and Gail Patterson, 70, and Heather Wilkinson, 66, and hospitalisation of Heather’s husband Ian.
Patterson claims the deaths have been all a horrible accident.
She took herself to hospital two days after the lunch and claimed she had eaten the identical meal as her in-laws however was discovered to be properly sufficient to be discharged by docs on August 1.
A baby safety employee yesterday mentioned Patterson instructed her she’d eaten half of her serve of the meat Wellington, and complained of feeling unwell and experiencing free bowel actions.
Defence barrister Colin Mandy SC right this moment cross-examined Dr Gerostamoulos, the Victorian Institute of Forensic Drugs’s chief toxicologist.
He requested whether or not some people may very well be “much less severely affected than others” after consuming loss of life cap mushrooms due to the quantity they’d ingested.
“Sure that is doable,” Dr Gerostamoulos mentioned.
“The age of the person is perhaps an element?” Dr Mandy continued.
“That may be an element,” he replied.
Dr Gerostamoulos additionally agreed that the load of the individual could also be an element, as may the person’s tolerance to the toxin.
Prosecutor Sarah Lenthall then re-examined the toxicologist.
“If two adults with no critical pre-existing well being situations consumed the identical quantity of the identical meal, which contained loss of life cap mushrooms, and one individual dies – what are the well being outcomes for the one who didn’t die?” she requested.
“There seemingly could be hostile outcomes for the one who survived, the severity of which can fluctuate,” Dr Gerostamoulos replied.
Extra pictures of the poisoned beef Wellington have been proven to the jury right this moment, as Plant Well being Victoria diagnostics supervisor David Lovelock gave proof.
He carried out a second take a look at on stays of the meal and located no signal of loss of life cap mushrooms.
Dr Lovelock mentioned he did discover loss of life cap mushrooms inside a meals dehydrator, which had been seized by police from a tip days after the meal.
One other scientist, Camille Truong, additionally discovered no signal of loss of life caps within the meal when inspecting it beneath a microscope.
Nevertheless, Dr Gerostamoulos instructed the jury right this moment he discovered loss of life cap mushroom toxins contained in the meal’s stays when he carried out chemical testing.
Justice Christopher Beale despatched the jury residence for the weekend with a warning after certainly one of their fellow jurors was dismissed for discussing the case with household and buddies.
“I do not need to sound like a damaged report however solely focus on the case together with your fellow jurors within the privateness of the jury room,” he mentioned.
The trial will resume on Monday.
LISTEN NOW: The Mushroom Trial
