All by way of the early years of his profession, M. Night time Shyamalan was flattered with (and dogged by) comparisons to the good Alfred Hitchcock. The comparisons had been affordable, however by no means fairly proper. Sure, Shyamalan, like Hitchcock, made twisty suspense motion pictures. However in contrast to Hitchcock, Shyamalan’s virtually all the time got here with some kind of supernatural bent. The man was lifeless all alongside. The dude who survived a horrible prepare crash was an honest-to-god superhero. The apocalypse begins, and just one couple’s noble sacrifice can cease it.
Alfred Hitchcock would by no means have made The Sixth Sense, or Unbreakable, or Knock on the Cabin. However he may need made Lure, the newest and most overtly Hitchcockian thriller Shyamalan’s ever made. In a way, Hitchcock did make it, as a result of Lure is a intelligent mixture of a complete bunch of various Hitchcock motion pictures, together with Psycho, Frenzy, Suspicion, and Rope.
From the latter, Shyamalan borrows the premise of a lurid, murderous melodrama largely set in a single location. Within the case of Lure, the placement is a Philadelphia sports activities enviornment on the day it hosts a live performance by a widely known pop star named Woman Raven (Shyamalan’s personal daughter Saleka, who’s a budding musician in her personal proper). Among the many hundreds of attendees on the live performance, Shyamalan narrows in on simply two: A rabid teenage fan named Riley (Ariel Donoghue) and her father Cooper (Josh Hartnett).
READ MORE: Each M. Night time Shyamalan Twist, Ranked From Worst to Finest
Talking right here as the daddy of a music-loving child named Riley, I can say this with some authority: There’s simply one thing a bit off about this Cooper man. No dad of youngsters this age is this chipper, this affected person, this darn good when he will get dragged to a pop live performance he has zero curiosity in. You’d should be loopy to be this upbeat about all this.
Positive sufficient, Cooper harbors a darkish secret, though Shyamalan reveals it to the viewers pretty rapidly: Cooper is definitely “The Butcher,” an notorious serial killer who’s claimed 12 victims, and already has a thirteenth locked away in an undisclosed location. Through the live performance, Cooper fakes a visit to the toilet, so he can get some sadistic jollies monitoring his captive through a secret app on his cellular phone.
Cooper is clearly a skillful and misleading psychopath, and it’s not lengthy earlier than he notices an unusually giant police presence at this Woman Raven live performance. Buddying as much as a sociable merch salesman (Jonathan Langdon), Cooper learns that the present is definitely an enormous entice designed to catch the Butcher. One way or the other, the cops discovered that he can be in attendance at Woman Raven’s present and hatched a plan to catch him as he leaves. There are officers posted at each exit. SWAT groups patrol the rooftops. Groups are grabbing any grownup man who even vaguely matches the Butcher’s description — and there aren’t that a lot of them at a pop live performance for teenage ladies! — for questioning. In the meantime, an FBI profiler (Hayley Mills) anticipates Cooper’s each transfer. There actually is likely to be no means out.
It’s not simply that Shyamalan has cooked up a reasonably engrossing (and non-supernatural) premise that offers Lure such old-fashioned Hitchcock-y vibes. He’s additionally borrowed all kinds of tips from the Grasp of Suspense. Hitch beloved to drive an viewers to determine with prison, as Shyamalan does right here. He was additionally pathologically paranoid concerning the police, supposedly relationship again to an incident from his personal childhood the place his father satisfied the native precinct to lock little Alfred as much as educate him a lesson. In Lure, in every single place Cooper turns, he’s hounded by faceless mobs of cops.
Hitchcock additionally beloved to mood disturbing moments with darkish humor, which Shyamalan does repeatedly in Lure. He fills the margins of the story with all kinds of quirky supporting characters, and he consistently forces Cooper to decide on between indulging his style for violence or sustaining his facade of non-threatening middle-aged dadhood — as when that pleasant merch salesman hooks Cooper up with a T-shirt, and concurrently arms him an unlimited field cutter.
Shyamalan additionally will get a terrific lead efficiency out of Hartnett, who manages to search out simply the appropriate stability between disturbing — and Cooper is commonly genuinely scary — and hilariously humorous, as when Cooper by chance walks right into a nest of ready SWAT snipers and has to suppose up a convincing lie on the spot. Cooper is certain to change into one in every of the actor’s signature roles.
Whereas it appeared like Lure’s trailers gave away most of its surprises, the film saved a bunch of tips up its sleeve that weren’t even hinted at in its advertising. I cannot spoil them right here, though I’ll say I’m not solely sure the entire later surprises work, or that the entire supporting gamers are giving performances of the identical caliber as Hartnett.
Nonetheless, I appreciated the truth that I might by no means anticipate the place Lure was headed. This, too, jogged my memory of Hitchcock, who all the time had a knack for realizing what to inform an viewers to get them within the theater, and what to withhold from them to be able to elicit the correct response. Again within the day, the countless comparisons between Shyamalan and Hitchcock felt like a little bit of a entice themselves. With Lure, although, there’s no level attempting to flee them.
Extra Ideas:
-Casting Hayley Mills — AKA the star of the unique Dad or mum Lure — in his personal film referred to as Lure that’s a few mum or dad who can also be a serial killer is likely to be the funniest factor in any Shyamalan movie.
-You may name Shyamalan casting his up-and-coming musician daughter because the world’s largest pop star an act of shameless nepotism. You might additionally argue that in a film concerning the excessive lengths a loving father will go to to be able to indulge his musically-inclined daughter, it was the one thematically acceptable selection.
-Because the dad of a candy woman named Riley, who takes her to issues I’ve completely zero curiosity in, who tries to encourage her passions even after they appear far-fetched, who would do virtually something to guard her from damage or hurt, who has been recognized to get pissed off on the mother and father of her associates after they do issues to upset her, however who is totally not a serial killer, I have to inform you I nonetheless did discover a honest quantity of this film fairly relatable.
RATING: 7/10
M. Night time Shyamalan Twists, Ranked
From The Sixth Sense and past, we have ranked each M. Night time Shyamalan twist from worst to finest.
Gallery Credit score: Emma Stefansky
