Star Wars: Tales of the Jedi
“Star Wars: Tales of the Jedi is extra Clone Wars consolation meals that expands upon fan-favorite characters, however gives little that we have not seen already.”
Professionals
- Dooku’s character arc is well-executed
- The animation type is additional refined
- Ahsoka’s origin is great
Cons
- The pacing is disjointed
- The storylines are too acquainted
- A missed alternative to characteristic extra Jedi
As Andor pushes Star Wars to new ranges of thematic nuance, narrative maturity, and manufacturing worth, some followers have taken its success as a chance to deride the opposite Star Wars tales round it. To an extent, that’s comprehensible, because the gulf of high quality between Andor and, say, The Guide of Boba Fett, is pretty massive. Nonetheless, success on this universe takes many shapes, and Tales of the Jedi is a part of a longstanding, profitable Star Wars custom that stands alongside live-action works: animation.
Reside-action narratives within the galaxy far, far-off have at all times set the tenor for the franchise. Nevertheless, devoted followers know that really wealthy storytelling typically exists in animation. Genndy Tartakovsky’s Clone Wars (2003) miniseries evoked a way of creative grandeur and mythology that the franchise has by no means recaptured, save maybe for the anime anthology sequence Visions. These two exhibits are a number of the greatest, most imaginative items of Star Wars media ever. Whereas Tales of the Jedi has moments of excellence, the sum of its components settles for being an alright, albeit overly acquainted, Star Wars expertise.
Assembly the requirements of contemporary Star Wars animation
Star Wars: Tales of the Jedi is simply the newest in a protracted line of animated tasks that really hit their stride within the time between Revenge of the Sith and The Power Awakens. Probably the most well-known animated sequence are actually these related to Dave Filoni: The Clone Wars (2008) and Rebels. Each nestle neatly into the core Skywalker Saga, filling within the gaps across the authentic and prequel trilogy movies. For as a lot as they serve to help the flicks, although, additionally they search to widen our view of two galaxy-defining conflicts. Every is completely price watching, however Rebels is arguably stronger, persevering with the traditions and methods from The Clone Wars with a tighter runtime and extra considerate narrative arcs.
However, The Clone Wars is actually the extra well-liked present. Its fanbase is huge, and Disney+ has been significantly variety to it, dropping ostensibly 4 extra seasons of the sequence: the right, closing Clone Wars season, two seasons of The Unhealthy Batch, and now Tales of the Jedi. Understanding this context is crucial to understanding each Tales’ strengths and weaknesses.
Star Wars: Tales of the Jedi has the pacing and scope of Clone Wars (2003) or Visions. Its six-episode format leaves no time for the filler that slowed down the long-form animated exhibits, together with the oddly bloated Disney+ season of The Clone Wars. Every episode has an outlined goal, principally exploring the rise of Ahsoka Tano and the corruption of then-Jedi Grasp Dooku. These additionally profit from an animation group well-versed in its home type, which makes the present seems to be nice.
Nevertheless, nearly all of the episodes really feel encumbered by the data that The Clone Wars is maybe essentially the most universally-praised Star Wars media because the authentic trilogy. The results of this data is a string of vignettes that fall into a really acquainted entice: an over-reliance on fan service.
As such, Tales of the Jedi is straightforward to advocate to anybody who already enjoys The Clone Wars, however that’s not an emphatic advice. What made the earlier animated exhibits so efficient was how they discovered an attention-grabbing stability between increasing previously-established lore and constructing on prime of it. Tales of the Jedi walks so carefully alongside each the earlier exhibits and movies that little right here feels ingenious; as a substitute, the present seems like a compilation of deleted scenes to fit in round tales we already love.
Revisiting Clone Wars favorites, for higher and worse
The three episodes centralized round Ahsoka really feel significantly drained. She’s one of many franchise’s greatest characters, however she’s additionally been featured throughout The Clone Wars, Rebels, The Mandalorian, and now an upcoming present of her personal. Other than the wonderful beginning episode detailing her youth, which hits all the correct notes of Power-sensitive spiritualism, it seems like we study little new about Ahsoka. There are some great moments in her closing episode (which is able to go unspoiled right here), however even these circle concepts that we simply explored in Obi-Wan Kenobi.
Exploring Dooku’s flip to the Darkish Aspect is markedly extra compelling. Dave Filoni exhibits us lore and character components which have solely been alluded to in tv or movie by means of asides in dialog or off-hand references. Like one of the best episodes of The Clone Wars, the tales that chronicle his rising skepticism surrounding the Jedi Order reveal new truths concerning the character within the context of completely authentic situations. Episode 2, “Justice,” and episode 3, “Decisions,” are particularly robust on this regard. Every presents a contained story with a visually-distinct backdrop that succeeds in narrative and theme.
Dooku’s closing episode turns into a bit too constricting in how tightly it wraps across the plot beats of The Phantom Menace, however it nonetheless permits for moments of emotional reflection that deepen the Depend. Though, its pacing feels a bit stilted, which is an issue throughout your complete sequence. Every vignette’s skill to really feel cohesive and full in roughly 10 to fifteen minutes is variable. Some do work properly with their truncated runtime. Episode 5, “Observe Makes Excellent,” although, feels extra like a chapter from an Expanded Universe ebook relatively than a brief story with a satisfying starting, center, and finish.
What might’ve been
It’s tough to not need extra from this sequence. This might’ve been a beautiful alternative to discover six completely different Jedi Knights throughout the six episodes, maybe providing solely two that adopted these fan-favorite characters. Star Wars animation gives the uncommon alternative to go wild with fantasy situations that might be deeply impractical in stay motion, and right here we might’ve seen alien Jedi on sprawling battlefields that’ll by no means seem on the silver display. That’s what each Clone Wars sequence targeted on so typically. In Tales of the Jedi, although, we simply get lots of moments that really feel as if they may’ve been slotted into Kenobi as flashbacks or into the upcoming Ahsoka present.
In the end, although, a few of these criticisms could also be railing towards Tales of the Jedi’s central intent. Its purpose, from the outset, was to supply extra of The Clone Wars. That’s precisely what it supplies. And, regardless of a scarcity of ambition within the storytelling, the present nonetheless does handle to curate moments that additional our favourite characters’ emotional growth and backstories. Plus, it’s arduous to withstand seeing Anakin and Ahsoka collectively once more, even when we now have numerous hours of that already. Simply being again on this pocket of the universe feels good.
For the time being, the anthology seemingly covers lots of floor. We watch Ahsoka develop up, and we see Dooku reject his previous. Upon reflection, although, it typically seems like we’re protecting little or no. With uncommon exceptions, all we see are extensions of moments and character traits outlined elsewhere. The Clone Wars and Rebels proved that you just don’t have to go to a brand new period to inform wealthy tales which develop the universe, all of the whereas protecting one foot on the fan service pedal. Tales of the Jedi has one foot on that pedal too, however it has the opposite foot on the brake.
Star Wars: Tales of the Jedi‘s six episodes are actually streaming on Disney+.
Editors’ Suggestions
