We acquired a Pleasure-themed installment of Station 19.
Sadly, after Station 19 Season 7 Episode 3, our Spherical Desk is not feeling very prideful, as they categorical blended emotions about how the sequence tackled the theme and who the hour centered.
The installment included a blast from the previous when Maya noticed her brother Mason protesting Pleasure and Travis and his father having a much-needed heart-to-heart.
Be part of our Station 19 Spherical Desk, which is comprised of Ellie MV, Heather M., and TV Fanatics Haley Whitmire White and Sara Trimble, as they break down the episode.
Be part of the dialogue beneath.
When you needed to grade the season to this point, what would it not be? What are you having fun with most in regards to the season, and what are you scuffling with most?
Ellie: Oh boy… *nervous snicker*
If I needed to grade the season to this point, it will be 0/10. I am sorry, however that is the worst season the writers have ever written. All the things feels so off like they wrote storylines for characters like Theo, Kate, Beckett, and Travis’s dad that no person cares about.
The newborn storyline with Marina does not look good as a result of it is rushed so badly. I battle with Andy as Captain. I am sick of Theo & Kate & Beckett.
Jack being the pet that everybody abandons again and again as a result of he’s an excessive amount of. So, that final season was a tough move for me. I am not having fun with something about this season, so I can not anticipate it to be over in 2 months.
Sara: I would fee this season at a 3/10 to this point. Thus far, I’ve but to be a fan of the ultimate season of Station 19.
They’re making an attempt to cram an excessive amount of into their final season whereas getting lazy with their motion scenes. I am having fun with lastly seeing Andy as Captain and she or he’s performed some good work to this point. I like that nobody is difficult her authority.
What I am not having fun with to this point is that there isn’t a pressure in any of the calls the station will get every episode. Every scene is well solved with little effort or forethought. And the scenes aren’t taking part in into one another. A lot of the drama is concentrated on the station moderately than exterior circumstances.
Final week, we came upon Carina was getting sued. They made it appear to be it was going to be an enormous deal. However this week, she and Bailey (Gray’s Anatomy) found there is no case. Does that imply the hysteria was for nothing?
And I agree with Ellie about all of the random storylines with minor characters, like Travis’s dad, and the rushed storyline between Carina and Maya and their adoption.
Haley: I will be extra beneficiant and provides them a 5/10 this season, however that is solely as a result of I do love these characters, and I wish to imagine that the season’s lackluster begin is constructing to one thing nice.
I would be happier if we acquired extra of Jack Gibson and fewer rushed, painful storylines. I am having fun with seeing Andy be captain; she’s labored laborious for this job and deserves it. All the things else is meh for me proper now.
Heather: Proper now, I hope the season will get higher, however the final three episodes acquired a 3/10 from me, too.
It is the writing. All the things is being rushed, and I do know that is not totally the author’s fault, however nothing feels linked anymore. The tales are uneven, and an excessive amount of is thrown into the combo. It simply does not really feel just like the Station 19 that we’ve got beloved.
What are your ideas on the sequence tackling a lot at a Pleasure occasion?
Ellie: As a queer fan, I’ve to say that the Pleasure occasion was dangerous. It was dangerous as a result of they made the Pleasure about homophobia when it is alleged to be a protected place for queer folks.
It was alleged to be about illustration, however the writers failed. It was dangerous as a result of they did not embody Maya & Carina in any respect, the feminine queer couple of the present. I hated it.
Sara: As with the remainder of the season, Station 19 Season 7 Episode 3 lacked the stress and menace of life anticipated of fireside responder exhibits. The panic that occurred from a automobile backfiring was actually excessive, like they wished to reference a mass capturing however did not wish to do the clique motion.
And with all of the hysteria that occurred, you are making an attempt to inform me that the one medical difficulty was a drag queen getting hung up on a trailer? And even that fell flat because it was simply mounted with no teamwork from the workforce.
Then, the bizarre storyline of the hate group that simply conveniently included the brother of the one homosexual feminine firefighter.
I used to be a bit irritated by Andy Herrera’s aggressive habits after the group session. She antagonists them after which blames them for upsetting Pru. It was unprofessional and never consultant of how a hearth captain ought to act.
Haley: It is humorous; I simply submitted an article about this kind of factor and its prevalence in Shondaland. Why is it at all times girls and the LGBTQ+ group who should take these crises on?
I am additionally a queer fan, and the entire Pleasure factor was an enormous bummer for a number of causes. Let me soar on my soapbox.
First, I did not like that they took so many alternatives to have LGBTQ+ characters say bizarre, sexualized issues to and/or in regards to the firefighters. It feeds into the stereotype that each one homosexual individuals are going to flirt with everybody it doesn’t matter what.
Second: Can we please have some pleasure on this group? The rationale the automobile backfiring was so scary was as a result of gun violence is such an enormous difficulty on this nation, and any time the LGBTQ+ group gathers in massive numbers, the concern of one thing horrible occurring is actual.
I might hold going, however we might be right here all day.
Heather: I agree with everybody about this Pleasure occasion. It was not performed effectively.
Too many dangerous stereotypes exist, such because the three sufferers who appeared excessive on one thing and performing out of the unusual. Throw within the “psychic” woman telling us every particular person’s difficulty. It felt unsuitable. Then we’ve got all of the hate stuff, which is one thing we concern occurring at Pleasure occasions. I do not assume the way in which it was dealt with was performed effectively.
I did not thoughts Andy being defensive of Roz, however as a substitute of getting Andy sink to the extent of those protestors, I want we had seen her dealing with it in a different way. I would have preferred to have seen extra of how Roz felt.
Did we have to have a automobile backfiring to trigger panic? Did we have to see a hateful man having his life saved? Did we’d like a Pleasure occasion crammed with little or no pleasure and delight? By no means.
Did you agree with Eli’s evaluation of Travis and his studying him for filth? Do you assume that is the final of Eli?
Ellie: Oh boy, that scene the place Eli was calling Travis Montgomery out on his bullshit was pure gold. I freaking beloved it !!! Eli was proper about Travis, so I am glad somebody referred to as him out. Let’s hope it opens Travis’s eyes.
It seems to be like Eli & Travis have been performed in that episode, so I feel it’s Eli’s final. Perhaps Travis will probably be single any longer; who is aware of?
Sara: I agree with Ellie that it was nice seeing Travis not get away with dishonest. Not after the massive match he threw when he was the one serving to his boyfriend cheat within the earlier season. Eli additionally referred to as Travis out about how he had acted along with his father and boyfriend.
Your entire storyline for Travis this season has been disappointing. He was once my favourite character, particularly as soon as I began hating Jack throughout his meltdown. However now they’ve corrupted the candy, ethical man we supported as mayor-to-be.
It may very well be the final we see of Eli. Or we might see a rekindling of the romance between Eli and Andy. I at all times most popular that pairing over the Eli/Travis coupling.
Haley: Yeah, good for Eli for standing up for himself and never accepting how Travis has been treating him. I nonetheless love Travis, flaws and all, however he deserved to be referred to as out.
I feel we’re performed with Eli on Station 19. It is a brief season — the writers try to wrap up all the pieces they will. I assume we’ll see a Travis and Emmett endgame, and the present needed to eliminate Eli first.
Heather: I used to be so glad to listen to all the pieces Eli mentioned to Travis. It wasn’t malicious; it was heartfelt with robust love. I appreciated that Eli put apart his harm about dishonest to inform Travis that the breakup was about Travis displaying his true colours.
I really like Travis and hate what’s been written for him this season, but when that is the course the present goes with him, then Travis higher take this as an enormous wake-up name.
Associated: How The Resident Falls Wanting the Good Netflix Binge Watch
I feel we’re performed with Eli. I do not see Eli as somebody like Emmett, who runs again to Travis. Even when Travis have been to come back round and be a greater particular person in relationships, Eli does not appear the sort to offer a 3rd probability to somebody.
Particularly somebody who cheated on him. One thought, although: I hope they do not have Eli return to Andy. That will be an excessive amount of.
What’s your response to that highly effective second and dialog between Travis and his father about letting go of disgrace?
Ellie: My response was, what the fuck? As a result of it seems to be just like the writers have forgotten that Travis was by no means ashamed of his personal sexuality. He’s a proud homosexual firefighter, so I didn’t perceive that scene along with his father.
Sara: On condition that each males reside overtly, it felt awkward and misplaced. It was bizarre that his dad was speaking about dwelling in disgrace when he did so for thus lengthy.
Whereas Travis at all times lived life as he was with out hiding his sexuality. Judgment has by no means been a part of Travis’s persona; I do not like seeing it now.
Haley: It is so attention-grabbing listening to your ideas right here as a result of I completely disagree! In my view, Travis has proven lots of disgrace about his sexuality all through the present. Vic referred to as him out as a result of, as his finest buddy, she’d seen him do it.
Greater than as soon as, we have seen Travis act like he is by some means a superior form of homosexual particular person. He nearly appears extra palatable to straight folks as a result of he is usually reserved and never flamboyant. Even on this episode, he exhibits disdain for Pleasure occasions and acts like he is above them.
Associated: The Rookie: Broadcast TV Wants Extra Villains Like Elijah Stone
It was important for Travis’s character to have his father take duty for that disgrace. Travis internalized his father’s bullying his complete life. He might not have stayed within the closet, however he carried the disgrace his father placed on him.
So, for Paul to come clean with it and launch Travis from it was actually highly effective.
Heather: I completely agree with Haley right here.
Simply because Travis is out as a homosexual man does not imply that he hasn’t had disgrace. It has been talked about a number of instances since we discovered about his historical past along with his father. His father popping out and Travis realizing that his dad was projecting onto him did not make that disgrace go away.
Even Diane tried to assist Travis see that he was carrying disgrace with out realizing his historical past along with his dad. And she or he picked up on it in season 3 due to his lack of respect for Emmett being within the closet and dishonest on his girlfriend.
So far as the scene with Paul, it made me cry. It felt highly effective to lastly have Paul acknowledge what he had performed to Travis.
I appreciated that Paul did not make that dialog about him and his personal internalized homophobia however all about its impact on Travis.
I want there have been extra of an “I am sorry” in there, too, however I feel what he mentioned to Travis about him needing to let go of the disgrace is precisely what Travis wanted to listen to.
Then again, one thing that annoyed me about this story is that this story ought to have been performed final season. The final time we noticed Paul, Nari was leaving him, and Travis was brokenhearted for his mother and father, and you would inform he felt dangerous for his father.
This occurred in season 5. At that time, it appeared like they have been beginning to mend the connection, however then we spent a complete season 6 centered on Travis operating for mayor as a substitute of him coping with this.
Mason returned however in an sudden manner. Share your ideas on this storyline and what it might imply shifting ahead.
Ellie: I at all times wished Mason again on the present, however NOT LIKE THIS.
To start with, I’d have preferred to have him again earlier than within the final season. And second of all, I’d have preferred to see him being another person however not a homophobic protestor on the Pleasure.
I perceive that Maya & Mason have grown up in a poisonous setting with an abusive father. Nonetheless, Mason might have grow to be higher like an artist, so I am disillusioned on this storyline. And I do not know what it might imply shifting ahead as a result of the writers have the talents to drop storylines, so I am afraid we cannot see Mason after this.
Sara: I felt like his look was misplaced, and it was a last-minute determination to make Maya emotional throughout what was alleged to be her celebration day. Why deliver him in at this level within the present?
Will Mason reappear in a later episode as a part of the storyline? In any other case, what was the purpose of his look? If the writers do not clarify how he fell in with the unsuitable crowd, why even present him in any case this time? Will he change his tune about homosexual relationships when he finds out he is an uncle? Or will it escalate issues?
Haley: This sucked. It simply…actually sucked. It is actually painful to be hated for who you’re, particularly when it is household. My coronary heart broke for Maya. I do not know if they’re going to deliver Mason again, however I can solely hope that in the event that they do, it will be in a redeeming manner.
She additionally needed to save the lifetime of one of many protesters after being the topic of his hatred moments earlier than. That may’t have been straightforward, however she was wonderful, skilled, and heroic.
Heather: I really feel aligned with what Sara mentioned. It simply felt like one other factor they only wished to throw in there.
Truthfully, I do not care a lot about Mason. We final noticed him in season 1 when Maya tried to assist him, and he wished nothing to do along with her then. Maya has by no means tried to trace him down and mend that relationship since then. So why can we even must see him now?
Associated: Gray’s Anatomy Evaluate: Stroll on the Ocean
And on this context? Maya already has a hateful father. She did deal with seeing Mason favorably for me, however I simply do not assume he’s somebody essential sufficient in her life to have thrown again into the combo.
Layoffs are imminent because the mayor goes again on his deal. What are your theories on what this might imply for Natasha and the station shifting ahead?
Ellie: Oh boy, I am curious to see the layoffs. Who’s going to be fired? Theo? Kate? Beckett? Maya?
Jack will not be a firefighter anymore, so I feel he has misplaced his job. Now, my concept is that somebody will get fired. It may very well be a plot twist. Like Sullivan? *evil snicker*
Sara: Natasha Ross was a idiot to imagine something the mayor has mentioned up so far.
She deserves no matter occurs to her as a result of she ought to have been ready for this. I would not be shocked if we see Natasha’s profession finish and perhaps Sullivan’s as he quits in protest in opposition to her unfair firing.
As for who’s to be fired, it may very well be anybody confused about how the writers are going. It is nearly like they do not have a imaginative and prescient for a way the present will finish, in order that they make issues up each week. May or not it’s that Maya will get fired, and it expands the plot line with Carina’s being sued, their IVF, and adopting the child?
Haley: When the mayor mentions layoffs, and Natasha pulls that shocked Pikachu face, I am simply sitting right here like, “What on the planet did you count on whenever you made a shady take care of a politician?!”
I hope they lay off Kate (or kill her, I am not choosy) and perhaps Beckett, though I warmed as much as him slightly on this episode. After which they need to have Natasha lay down on her personal sword out of loyalty as a result of she brought on this mess along with her little deal within the hospital. There. The price range disaster was solved.
Heather: Ugh, I hate to consider the place they’ll go together with this layoff storyline. I’ve seen some attention-grabbing theories about Maya or Ben leaving for his or her households or Travis leaving due to what Eli mentioned about him turning into a firefighter. I would hate to see anybody go away the station.
Additionally, I mentioned it in Station 19 Season 6, however this mayor comes off as shady.
He knew Travis did not wish to be mayor and performed him to get the votes. He’s having fun with making Ross squirm. And I hope that Ross and Andy discover a strategy to push again in opposition to Osman, particularly after he promised Travis to extend the SFD price range by 15%, not lower it by 10%. It doesn’t matter what, although, for the love of all the pieces, eliminate Kate!
Theo nonetheless has emotions for Vic. Are you invested on this and them?
Ellie: Nope. Subsequent query!
Sara: Agreed with Ellie. I used to be by no means invested within the Vic and Theo relationship to start with. I want to see Vic Hughes deal with herself moderately than being in yet one more relationship as she has been all through your complete sequence.
However was there ever a query of him not having emotions for her? A glance says all of it, even when he has been messing round with the annoying beginner who doesn’t match into the 19 household.
Haley: Ugh, I can not assist it. I am rooting for Thictoria, not simply because that couple’s identify is hilarious. I need Theo to acknowledge his shortcomings and get remedy, after which I need them to reside fortunately ever after.
Heather: I am with you right here, Haley.
I beloved Vic and Theo collectively, and sure, he was horrible to her as interim captain. And I do not wish to defend his habits, however the way in which he acted is tied to the truth that not solely did his father die within the line of obligation, however he was answerable for Michael’s dying as a captain.
He has mentioned he is at all times been nervous, and I do not assume he realized how nervous he could be within the function once more. Additionally, Vic was not good to him both. They went by way of some robust spots collectively and got here out stronger.
If he can notice that he was a horrible boyfriend when he did not help her in her journey to a psych diploma, I feel that is one thing they will work by way of. Theo is misplaced with out her proper now, however he’s realizing some issues. So, I’m invested on this relationship.
What was your favourite second from the episode? Do you may have any extra ideas?
Ellie: My favourite second from the episode was when Eli referred to as Travis out. I loved the scene (and the tea). I additionally beloved the Bailey/Carina DeLuca scene. They’re good associates, and it’s totally good to see them collectively speaking about work, their spouses, their lives…
Sara: I missed seeing Jack on this episode.
As a lot as he helps Maya and Carina and loves little Pru, I anticipated to see him on Pleasure Day. He may not have been in a position to stroll the route, however he might have performed a wave standing within the crowd or a pop-by go to on the station through the dance get together. It did not appear proper with out him.
I do not know that I had a favourite scene for this week.
Your entire episode was dry and didn’t maintain my consideration very effectively. I discovered myself gravitating extra in direction of my telephone than the characters. I did benefit from the tender second between Bailey and Carina, and it was good to see the put-together physician all matted and overwhelmed, as most new mothers find yourself being with a new child.
Haley: I agree with Ellie in regards to the Bailey & Carina scene (the nod to Bailey’s being pregnant loss and second of respect there was good, too). I really like Miranda and am at all times glad to see her on Station 19.
And Sara, I completely agree about Jack and the parade. Why would not he be there? Is senseless. It looks as if a no brainer to have him there in (what ought to have been) a chill occasion the place the household was all collectively.
The episode was a disappointment, and I am normally a sucker for Pleasure-themed episodes. I hope the season picks up as a result of I am uninterested in going to mattress unhappy on Thursday nights!
Heather: I, too, beloved seeing Bailey and Carina collectively. I really like Bailey and the way she is there for her associates. She is an excellent girl.
If I needed to decide a favourite scene, it will be the dance get together and seeing everybody dancing and feeling slightly united. It was a good suggestion to empower the LGBTQ+ group after what occurred on the occasion.
Seeing Symone was a spotlight. Music generally is a nice unifier, and dancing is a good launch and a strategy to categorical your self, so it simply felt like we had this group coming collectively in any case this ugliness.
Over to you, Station 19 Fanatics. Do you agree with us? Hold forth beneath!
You may catch Station 19 on ABC on Thursdays at 10/9c. You may stream the next day on Hulu.
Jasmine Blu is a senior employees author for TV Fanatic. She is an insomniac who spends late nights and early mornings binge-watching manner too many exhibits and binge-drinking manner an excessive amount of tea. Her eclectic style makes her an unpredictable viewer with an appreciation for complicated characters, various illustration, dynamic duos, compelling tales, and responsible pleasures. You will undoubtedly discover her obsessively live-tweeting, waxing poetic, and chatting up fellow Fanatics and readers. Follow her on X.
