The electrical automotive world is significantly heating up, with various high-end electrical crossovers now obtainable, albeit nonetheless at a better worth than comparable gas-powered vehicles. The Tesla Mannequin Y is without doubt one of the first of those, providing the Tesla design, a high-tech software program expertise, and extra. However one other one of many older of those fashions is the Volkswagen ID.4, which was first launched in 2021 and likewise presents among the many higher electrical automotive experiences on the market.
Can the ID.4 compete with one of many best-selling electrical vehicles on the market? We put the 2 head-to-head to seek out out.
Design
The very first thing to check between these two vehicles is design, and so they take a barely completely different method.
The Tesla Mannequin Y, for starters, appears to be like like different Tesla vehicles. It presents the identical trendy method, with slanted headlights on the entrance, and a minimalistic look total. Tesla’s design has been ageing just a little, given the truth that it has largely remained unchanged for a while now — however there’s no denying that the Mannequin Y nonetheless appears to be like typically smooth.
Sleeker than the ID.4, anyway. The ID.4 isn’t essentially an ugly automotive, however it definitely doesn’t look as trendy or smooth as many different electrical vehicles. I discover the ID.4 to be much less smooth than most prime electrical vehicles on the market — in my view, the Mannequin Y, Kia EV6, Hyundai Ioniq 5, and Ford Mustang Mach-E all look leagues higher.
Usually, the ID.4 presents a extra conservative method to design, and also you wouldn’t know that it’s electrical simply by it. It has a rounded roof alongside the highest, with a light-weight bar that stretches alongside the again of the automotive. Regardless of not liking the general design, I do like that contact.
Design is mostly subjective, so for those who disagree, be happy to ignore this part. For my part, although, this one goes to Tesla.
Winner: Tesla Mannequin Y
Inside and tech
The design ethos that Tesla and Volkswagen tackle the skin continues on the within. That’s to say, the Tesla Mannequin Y is minimalistic and trendy, whereas the Volkswagen ID.4 appears to be like just a little extra conventional.
Now, that might not be a superb factor for everybody. Tesla has been pretty criticized for transferring too a lot into the display. The ID.4 retains a lot of steering wheel controls, that means that you simply don’t need to dive into settings for lots of the controls. You’ll nonetheless have to make use of the display for local weather controls, although.
Tesla has a leg up within the tech part too. Tesla has labored arduous to make sure that its software program expertise is nice — and whereas its infotainment system may nonetheless be higher, it’s among the many finest on the market proper now. The ID.4’s infotainment system appears to be like dated and is more durable to navigate — although fortunately, not like the Tesla, it helps CarPlay and Android Auto. On the flip facet, the Mannequin Y has a a lot bigger infotainment show, which is good.
Different tech is just a little higher on the Tesla too. Tesla presents issues like cameras for safety and extra autonomous driving tech, regardless that a few of that comes at an additional price. The Tesla is simply extra high-tech than the ID.4. It will get the win right here.
Winner: Tesla Mannequin Y
Efficiency
Each the Mannequin Y and the ID.4 can be found with a number of powertrain choices. The usual Mannequin Y has a 5.0-second acceleration from 0 to 60 mph — however it jumps as much as 3.5 seconds for the Tesla Mannequin Y Efficiency. The Mannequin Y has a horsepower of between 425 and 455, once more, relying on the mannequin.
The Volkswagen ID.4, then again, doesn’t fairly match that — even the quickest ID.4, the ID.4 Professional S Plus, is slower than the slowest Mannequin Y at 5.8 seconds. It has a horsepower of between 201 and 295.
The Mannequin Y will get the win right here, fairly simply.
Winner: Tesla Mannequin Y
Vary and charging
Vary is without doubt one of the most necessary features of any trendy electrical automotive. The Tesla Mannequin Y is fairly good at vary — providing 279 miles within the base Mannequin Y, and as much as 330 miles within the Mannequin Y Lengthy Vary. The ID.4 is kind of a bit decrease. The bottom mannequin of the ID.4 is the ID.4 Normal, and it has a spread of 209 miles, with the highest-range mannequin being the ID.4 Professional S at 275 miles.
When the Mannequin Y does run out of juice, it has the good thing about having the ability to use Tesla’s giant community of Superchargers and different public chargers, whereas the ID.4 can’t use Tesla chargers simply but. The Mannequin Y can cost at as much as 250 kilowatts, which is able to get you from 10% to 80% cost in 27 minutes. The ID.4 helps a charging velocity of 135kW, and it’ll get you from 10% to 80% in round 33 minutes.
Regardless of the way you have a look at this class, Tesla wins.
Winner: Tesla Mannequin Y
Pricing and availability
The Tesla Mannequin Y could have gained all of the classes to date, however worth is an space the place the Volkswagen ID.4 may acquire some traction. The bottom worth of the Tesla Mannequin Y is $47,740 for the usual vary mannequin. The bottom worth of the Volkswagen ID.4, nevertheless, is a a lot decrease $38,995. Certain, you might spend extra on higher-end fashions, however the reality is that if you wish to spend much less, then the Volkswagen ID.4 is a more sensible choice.
Each vehicles are available — however contemplating the worth, this one goes to Volkswagen.
Winner: Volkswagen ID.4
Total winner: Tesla Mannequin Y
This was all the time going to be a tricky competitors for Volkswagen. Even for those who disregard subjective issues like design, the Tesla Mannequin Y nonetheless performs higher and has an extended vary and quicker charging. Nevertheless it’s additionally costlier — you’ll need to pay for these higher options. In the event you don’t thoughts spending the additional money and are deciding between these two vehicles, then the Mannequin Y might be a greater choice — however for those who may stand to avoid wasting money, the ID.4 remains to be a strong EV.
Editors’ Suggestions
