When Calls the Heart Season 12 Report Card: The Series Improved Greatly, But Still Has Issues

Issues nonetheless appear lopsided in Hope Valley.

When Calls the Coronary heart is the Hallmark Channel’s longest-running sequence. When dramas final that lengthy, they run into points balancing characters and storylines because the solid grows.

Whereas When Calls the Coronary heart Season 12 improved considerably over the past season, it nonetheless has a number of points to work out.

Whereas many episodes have been nonetheless community-focused, a number of characters have been solely pop-up characters and didn’t obtain a lot of their very own storyline.

The sequence additionally added a number of new characters new characters as effectively to their already huge solid.

Let’s focus on one of the best and worst of When Calls the Coronary heart Season 12.

Finest Episode: When Calls the Coronary heart Season 12 Episode 11 – Having Religion

When Calls the Coronary heart Season 12 Episode 11 was probably the most transferring because it demonstrated a mom’s worst concern.

Diabetes was so totally different 100 years in the past with restricted remedies, and insulin was solely being examined. It was a leap of religion to strive it on younger youngsters, and Elizabeth needed to persuade the physician to offer Little Jack an opportunity.

“Having Religion” confirmed how far Hope Valley would go to help Elizabeth and her household. Some have been small gestures like offering meals and a listening ear.

Nonetheless, Mike and Mei canceled their trip and traveled to Toronto to attraction to the physician and retrieve the insulin. 

I additionally appreciated how the remainder of the city rallied to get sufficient check topics in Hope Valley so Religion may administer the insulin regionally to Little Jack since they wanted their very own clinic.

Nobody was going to let him down. He was one in all them, and watching how the kids strived arduous to cheer him up made me cry.

Possibly that’s as a result of these days, older children don’t give younger ones the time of day. Issues have been easier 100 years in the past, and generally that was higher.

Worst Episode: When Calls the Coronary heart Season 12 Episode 9 – Buried Treasure

When Calls the Coronary heart Season 12 Episode 9 grated on my nerves. It had the potential to tie lots of the arcs collectively, however everybody felt remoted as a substitute.

One of the best half was watching Woody Garrison with Oliver and Allie. He wished to please Sonny however didn’t wish to mess with a Mountie cadet or a Mountie’s daughter.

Molly additionally had some nice strains, reminiscent of when she seen the children with Woody and knowledgeable Elizabeth. It was probably the most she had been utilized in ages. I think that, having a daughter, she naturally anxious about teenagers.

Seeing the city rally collectively to seek out the children was nice, even when Elizabeth, Allie, and Oliver held their very own.

The issue got here later as a result of nobody remembered Lucas had reservations on the cafe. First, I nonetheless suppose he would have helped to seek out Allie and Oliver. He’s keen on them.

However he appeared so remoted, they usually have been fortunate he was a very good sport concerning the makeshift meal.

Extra importantly, what would have been the purpose of Ava’s storyline if she hadn’t been linked to the Garrisons or McGinty?

Revealing that she got here to Hope Valley to cover from a con artist, unrelated to both arc, was a waste of time.

Regardless of how a lot Hallmark and I like Tiera Skovbye, we didn’t want any extra new characters.

Finest Elizabeth and Nathan Second: Going Undercover Collectively on When Calls the Coronary heart Season 12 Episode 7

I’m not a passionate Nathan and Elizabeth shipper, however watching them undercover made me recognize their connection extra.

In my evaluation of When Calls the Coronary heart Season 12 Episode 7, I discussed that their undercover gig jogged my memory of Timeless, which additionally endeared me to them.

Danny and Diane Demarco have been enjoyable aliases, and watching them maintain their tales straight was hilarious.

Whereas Trudy Davis was entertained, Toddy Davis apparently thought they have been mendacity and stored on the lookout for a clue.

Often, there’s time to organize equivalent tales, they usually needed to wing it, as they needed to with their improvised duet.

“Dance the Night time Away” allowed Nathan and Elizabeth an epic date night time with ritzy romance, and he or she lastly skilled life with one in all his circumstances. She additionally witnessed the explanation why he fell in love along with her. This was written for the followers.

Character Who Obtained Shafted: Henry Gowen

Henry appears to have been relegated to giving recommendation, and he’s a lot greater than that.

I used to be hopeful he could be used extra when he and Joseph determined to start out the hazelnut enterprise collectively. Nonetheless, we solely noticed them in enterprise for one episode as a result of it was demolished when Lucas returned to city.

Supposedly, he nonetheless managed the enterprise, however we by no means noticed it.

Henry seen Emily’s enterprise sense and mentored her, however once more, it was a blip on the radar. I had hoped to see this develop over time since Henry has grown from being remoted to turning into keen on the kids.

He’s labored in lots of companies and appeared so pleased with Emily that I hoped she would develop into their apprentice. Henry must be seen in numerous methods.

Most Improved Character: Invoice Avery

When Calls the Coronary heart Season 12 was a very good season for Invoice.

He and Rosemary’s partnership was so profitable that they teamed up once more to unravel the thriller concerning the Garrison gang and the gold coin.

It was amusing as a result of Invoice is normally by the books, and Rosemary finds solutions it doesn’t matter what. Nonetheless, their partnership thrived, they usually have been entertaining once they gave Nathan his new persona.

Invoice even acquired a second likelihood at love when an previous work buddy Georgie McGill (Melissa Gilbert) got here to city to help with the case.

It had been lengthy because the sequence explored Invoice’s love life, and he had been greater than a enjoyable uncle or a caring buddy.

It was refreshing to see him and Georgie discover long-buried and unresolved emotions for each other. Jack Wagner and Melissa Gilbert labored superbly collectively, and we hope she returns as Georgie subsequent season. Invoice deserves extra happiness.

Character That Continues To Get Misused: Lucas Bouchard

Hopefully, the When Calls the Coronary heart writers will return to fundamentals with Lucas Bouchard. Whereas he will get issues achieved, he doesn’t belong in politics.

He fights for folks and bettering locations. He’s not cutthroat.

I hated that we spent nearly half a season with Lucas and Lee as rivals once they in the end wished the identical aim.

Not less than somebody remembered that Lucas was keen on and would take heed to the kids. I used to be so relieved that he took Allie’s issues to coronary heart and developed a brand new proposal for the park.

It harm that his governership was recalled as his plan for the Nationwide State Park went by means of. However Lucas realized who he may depend on. I solely hate that we had two years of a political arc.

The query stays if Edie will return subsequent season. Whereas I loved her with Lucas, is there house for her on canvas?

Finest Recurring Character With a Storyline: Fiona Miller

It was terrific to have Fiona return for a number of episodes. Nonetheless, her return was combined.

Closing has all the time been confident, so whereas it was true for the time, it didn’t appear straightforward to course of that she would get married to raised her standing and profession.

Whereas this was a significant arc, we hated that she barely mentioned it along with her closest associates and spent extra time with Elizabeth, who had additionally damaged an engagement.

Fiona additionally appeared happier working the radio present with Rosemary and addressing essential points. Whereas Fiona had by no means been near Rosemary both, their relationship made extra sense career-wise.

They’d comparable objectives, and I used to be relieved that Fiona had determined to go up her personal present. Hopefully, we’ll see her once more. She’s a pressure!

New Character We Hope Returns in Season 13: Oliver Garrett

We had three profitable new characters, however bringing Oliver again makes probably the most sense. He suits in seamlessly with the opposite characters.

His backstory was heartwarming, and I hope the sequence touches on it extra. It must be addressed – he felt like he needed to escape since he didn’t wish to be a farmhand without end.

Oliver by no means turned carefree or childlike till coming to Hope Valley. Many foster children nonetheless really feel that manner, that their solely goal is to work.

Due to this fact, hopefully, the sequence delves into his household historical past, newfound friendships, and blossoming romance with Allie.

That received’t be very straightforward since he strives to please Nathan and shield her in any respect prices.

Total Grade: B-

The present season improved over When Calls the Coronary heart Season 11 as a result of the sequence felt like Hope Valley once more by coming collectively as a neighborhood.

They surrounded Elizabeth, Nathan, and the kids every time a disaster arose, whether or not Allie and Oliver have been in peril or Little Jack was sick.

The issue was that a lot of the storylines nonetheless concerned Elizabeth, Nathan, or Allie. Generally, Rosemary or Invoice have been concerned. The remainder of the city was hardly key gamers.

It nonetheless felt lopsided by way of story arcs. When Calls the Coronary heart has an enormous solid and lacks storyline equality.

It felt like we had far more of Rosemary than we did of Lee that season, and he or she works one of the best with him to even her out.

Religion barely had something to do after her emotional arc final season when she gained guardianship of Lily.

I wished to see extra of how they tailored to one another. Hopefully, with the brand new diabetes clinic, we’ll see Religion in motion.

They should handle that earlier than Season 13 as a result of followers additionally need tales concerning the Canfields, Mike and Mei, and Religion and Lily.

Among the finest moments have been the household arcs, as Elizabeth helped Allie by means of her teenage angst and the Canfields adjusted to Angela’s commencement.

Over to you, Hearties. What have been your favourite elements? How would you grade the season?

Please share your ideas under.

When Calls the Coronary heart returns in 2026.

Watch When Calls the Coronary heart On-line

TV Fanatic is looking for passionate contributors to share their voices throughout varied article sorts. Suppose you’ve gotten what it takes to be a TV Fanatic? Click on right here for extra data and subsequent steps.